I'd say it's more a matter of wasted potential.
I like it when a lot of things I like appear, but at the same time, sometimes I get a bit overwhelmed.
You know... it's one thing when we already have 1:1 zipmods with half-state features, and another when we have unfinished, or even lacking half-state features.
In times like these, where perfect ports have been around for a long time, I'd rather see something different, even from the same IP.
Otherwise, we stagnate. Time passes, years pass, the database grows, and for example, for individual IPs, instead of seeing ports for the rest of the characters, we have dozens, mostly the same three.
like an example of Bleach.
This reeks of ignorance/psycho rather than being a something fan.
A fan would be familiar with the topic and would choose something broader and more innovative for the IP they're interested in, rather than revisiting something that's been finished for the 30th time.
Sometimes, situations are so abstract that people choose the same character for the third time in a poll in the same author, for example, with Evaanxd. They give up on expanding the same IP in favor of reworking something that doesn't require it.
As a Bleach fan... i would never vote for Rangiku in ABC for the above reasons.
For example, Inoue Orihime was cool from ABC, because one thing we didn't have it back then, and two, there's a TYBW arc version.
Today we already have two versions of TYBW and one casual, and I hope I won't see the third/two one.
If this were to be another TYBW/Casual, I would much rather have one from the Arancar Arc, or some other character from the same IP that doesn't have ports.
Because it would be innovative.